aQsE
aQs
?
?
°èyT a
3?￥ %|ù5
#ü6 a
?Z
￥y
í
T1?
H |￥?4ê4 M?
v￥T¨òy
í￥×1?
4[
Saaty? 1970
M}4aQsE
AHP (Analytic Hierarchy Process)
AHP——B? ??D?
M2
￥ a"d aaQ ￥sZE
B aQsE￥'??
è ê4
j31
? ?
"￥1??v? ? a
n¨ a tHq?y
íê4
O(ê4
j31 )
P
2
?
P
1
I
P
3
z
"Sa
C
3
t
C
1
? ?
C
2
n¨
C
4
?
J
C
5
jo
5a
Z?a
“ê4
j31,
±?V?￥B
,
| %|ù5s1 3?aQ
"Sa O5a C
Z?a P
aμ ??í
í òaí
íW￥1"
¨M ?￥°LV
U b
YVMo1? ??ò5
"S￥ ?×#òZ
?
B5￥ ?× b
|
F ?×é?8 ??òZ?
"S￥
?× b
aQsE|??sD?
s2 ?
??[
??ó %|ù5￥?
2T b
aQsE￥'??
?1??
?_
í
í-W
11?¨M
=
1135/13/1
1125/13/1
3/12/117/14/1
55712
3342/11
A
ij
jiijnnij
a
aaaA
1
,0,)( =>=
×
!11?ò5 C
1
,C
2
,…,C
n
"S O￥×1?
ijji
aCC?:
A~?1??
A
^?oQ?
ê
4
j
3
1
1? A ?? C
1
,…,C
n
O￥ ?_
=
" "
"
"
712
42/11
A
?1?￥?Bá f ?
):(2/1
2112
CCa =
):(4
3113
CCa =
):(8
3223
CCa =
Bá1?
?Bá
?1?? ?_
=
n
nnn
n
n
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
A
"
" "
"
"
21
2
2
2
1
2
1
2
1
1
1
??Bá?1 ???Bá￥
?S?
n
wwwW ",,)1(
21
=
jiij
wwa /=
7
?_
~),,(
21
T
n
wwww "=
I3? ?Bá￥ f ?
?1?? ?_
=
n
nnn
n
n
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
A
"
" "
"
"
21
2
2
2
1
2
1
2
1
1
1
?1?? ?Bá￥ f ?
nkjiaaa
ikjkij
,,2,1,,, "==?
@
￥?oQ? A? Bá? ?
A￥?1 1 A￥·Bd
,+??1 n
A￥ ?B
_
^?? n ￥+?_
Bá?
?é
A￥BB+?_
VT1 ?_
??Bá ?
?S?
=
￥?
1?? Ayp¨??Kv+?? λ
￥+?_
T1 ?_
w '
wAw λ=
Saaty? |4 1~9——a
ij
|′
1,2,…,9# oQ
1,1/2,…,1/9
?1?? ?_
1?a
ij
2 4 6 8
1 3 5 7 9
ij
a
M]
< <
üA < ' <￥×1?
ji
CC,
L?????
￥
ji
CC,~
a
ij
= 1,1/2,,…1/9
￥×1?D
MQ
? ?DE a1?1?￥y
í?R?V 9?
¨ 1~3,1~5,…1~17,…,1
p
~9
p
(p=2,3,4,5),d+0.1~d+0.9
(d=1,2,3,4)? 27?1? ??
L è/?1?
?
?_
D
L=1?C 1~9?a b
Bá?_ A ???Bá￥
?S?
X? n ¨Bá?￥·Bd
,+??1 n
V￡ n¨?oQ?Kv+?? λ≥n, O λ =n
H1Bá?
1?
=
n
n
CI
λ
?lBá?·S,
CI v?Bá ?×
1
CI ￥vl? ?
Bá?·S RI——
E¤? a
ij
,?? A9
CI '¤ RI b
Saaty￥2T ?/
RI 0 0 0.58 0.90 1.12 1.24 1.32 1.41 1.45 1.49 1.51
n 12345 6 78 9
1110
? CR<0.1
HYVBá?_
?lBá?1
q CR = CI/RI
=
1135/13/1
1125/13/1
3/12/117/14/1
55712
3342/11
A
5a
"S￥ ?1??
oê4
j31 p?
5a
"S￥ ?
_
#Bá?_
Kv+?? λ=5.073
?_
+?_
w =(0.263,0.475,0.055,0.090,0.110)
T
018.0
15
5073.5
=
=CI
Bá?·S
Bá?·S RI=1.12 (°V )
YVBá
?_
Bá?1
q CR=0.018/1.12=0.016<0.1
F ?_
:? 2a
5? 1a
"S
￥ ?_
1
T
n
www ),,(
)2()2(
1
)2(
"=
]" p? 3a (Z? )? 2a
Bí
í (5 )￥ ?_
=
12/15/1
212/1
521
1
B
Z?a C
1
(? ? )
￥?1??
=
138
3/113
8/13/11
2
B
Z?a C
2
(n¨ )
￥?1??
…C
n
…B
n
Kv+?? λ
1
λ
2
…λ
n
?_
w
1
(3)
w
2
(3)
… w
n
(3)
? 3a? 2a￥9
2T
k
)3(
k
w
k
λ
k
CI
1
0.595
0.277
0.129
3.005
0.003 0.001 0 0.005 0
3.002
0.682
0.236
0.082
2
3
0.142
0.429
0.429
3
3.009
0.175
0.193
0.633
4
3
0.668
0.166
0.166
5
F ?_
w
(2)
0.263
0.475
0.055
0.090
0.110
RI 0.58 (n=3),CI
k
( VYVBá?_
Z? P
1
"S￥F ?×1 0.595×0.263+ …=0.300
Z?a
"S￥F ?_
1 (0.300,0.246,0.456)
T
T
n
www ),,(
)2()2(
1
)2(
"=
F
?_
? 1a O
? 2a C
1
,…C
n
? 3a P
1
,…P
m
nkwww
T
kmkk
,,2,1,),,(
)3()3(
1
)3(
" "==
? 2a? 1a￥ ?_
? 3a? 2aòí
í￥ ?_
],,[
)3()3(
1
)3(
n
wwW "=
/ ?
)2()3()3(
wWw =
5? 3a? 1a￥F ?_
? sa? 1a￥F ?_
? W
(p)
^?? pa?
p-1a ?_
F?￥ ?
)2()3()1()()(
wWWWw
sss
"
=
aQsE￥'??
1y ?aQs2
?
' ?s
L=ù5|μ1y
í1
7/sa
"S —
5·S —Z?`
a
s/a?Y7a
=
òy
í'
M? ? b
2/?1??
¨?1?E 1~9/òa
Ba
By
í￥
?1?? b
39
?_
iTBá?_
B?1??9
Kv+??+?_
TBá?
_ ?YV5+?_
1 ?_
b
49
F ?_
TFBá?_
*
F ?_
VT1 %|￥?
G b
= aQsE￥<W?¨
?¨
5× ü695 ?
÷?|s
￥
|?êù
N
3á %|?Y
{ Sùê
5á<2?aD
ìa +
Y? b
) ?ù5 ?? %| a
N as a??? b
y ?aQs2
?
^1oB?1μ?1 %
|a?D b
/?1??
^
G ??ü~? a
? <￥Eó b
SE8
L ?
S
l ?
+
Y
?
S/
￡
ü
×?
?
^
a, a? a ° a￡?vS
è 1SE
L ?s
yTê4
D
l
?
?
Z
2
?
1
"
ê
?
ê4￥?ê
è 2 yTê4
V￥rm
A
ü6rm
B
1
rm
B
2
ìarm
B
3
?
8
H
W
C
1
l
?
C
2
á
W
<
C
3
?
1
<
C
4
y
y
ü
<
C
5
?
?
V
L
C
6
?
a
Y
C
7
1
w
?
C
8
}
a
C
9
é
Z
L
C
10
C
11
B
D
1
a?
D
2
/
D
3
1VrmaQ2
è 3
~ aZ,
Z?￥ 4
V￥}N
A
ü6}N
B
1
ìa}N
B
3
}N
B
2
g
?
'
á
C
1
?
T
?
1
C
2
/
<
C
3
3
Z
T
C
4
?
Y
?
*
C
5
ì
%
C
6
ú
b
t
C
7
￡
￥
ê
?
C
8
3
￥
ê
C
9
B
D
1
a?
D
2
/
D
2
2V}NaQ2
è 3
~ aZ,
Z?￥ 4
?
N￥ S/?T
°¤
ü6
rm
C
11
W¤
ü6
rm
C
12
rm
C
13
D
M
￡
ü
C
21
D
7?
C
22
/
￡
ü
C
23
/
7?
C
24
rm C
1
￡
ü C
2
C
3
S/?T
N
è 4 S/?T
￥8
N
?,aQsE￥ ??ù5
?oQ?￥Kv+??
^?1?
$+?_
^?1?_
$Bá?·S
?Q??oQ?¤
íBá?￥?$
8"e9
?oQ?￥Kv+??+?_
$
1
I
1¨+?_
T1 ?_
$
?aQ2?? ??1??μ b ?
H8"¨
aQsE$
1,?oQ?￥Kv+??+?_
￥?é
? ? ? ? A ￥Kv+?? λ
^????
?+?_
w O
T
kT
k
k
ew
eAe
eA
)1,,1,1(,lim "==
∞→
?oQ?￥Kv+??
^?
+?_
^?_
b
? ? n¨?oQ? A￥Kv+?? λ ? n,
λ= n
^ A1Bá?￥ 1Hq b
Bá?·S ?l ?
1?
=
n
n
CI
λ
2,?oQ?Kv+??+?_
￥e9
ú ?9
￥ˉ?A1
e9
￥
±
^ ——Bá?￥ ?B
_
?
^+?_
Bá?
z￥?oQ?￥
_
??í
+?_
V |
?il/￥
ü ( b
E —— |
_
￥
ü (
=
14/16/1
412/1
621
A è
091.0077.01.0
364.0308.03.0
545.0615.06.0
w=
089.0
324.0
587.0
_
BB
ü (
=
286.0
974.0
769.1
Aw
wAw λ=
009.3)
089.0
268.0
324.0
974.0
587.0
769.1
(
3
1
=++=λ
ú ?2T,w=(0.588,0.322,0.090)
T
,λ=3.010
e
9
?E —— |
_
￥+
ü (
aE ——Y}
E
1 ? |
S_
w
(0)
,k:=0
!?úε
)()1(
~
kk
Aww =
+
2) 9
∑
=
+++
=
n
i
k
i
kk
www
1
)1()1()1(
~
/
~
3BB
4 ? T?
?5 k:=k+1,2
ε<?
+ )()1(
max
k
i
k
i
i
ww
∑
=
+
=
n
i
k
i
k
i
w
w
n
1
)(
)1(
~
1
λ
5) 9
3,+?_
T1 ?_
——?1?￥ ? ?r?
ù5
Bá? A, ?_
w=(w
1
,…w
n
)
T
,a
ij
=w
i
/w
j
A?Bá,?ê ?_
w
P w
i
/w
j
D a
ij
Mμ
D
l
μ i,j) b
2
11
),,1(
min
∑∑
==
=?
n
i
n
j
j
i
ij
niw
w
w
a
i
"
¨
EZE ?? w
dL?
Kl=e
L? ——
Kl=e
2
11
),,1(
lnlnmin
∑∑
==
=?
n
i
n
j
j
i
ij
niw
w
w
a
i
"
2TD?EM]
??]5 ??￥ ?_
?
]+?_
μ
I
1a? b
?1?
C
i
:C
j
(°¤1?
a
ij
~ ? <
)(
)2(2
ij
aA =
sj
n
s
isij
aaa
∑
=
=
1
)2(
a
is
a
sj
~ C
i
YV C
s
D C
j
￥1?
a
ij
(2)
~ 2? <
÷
Q? C
i
C
j
￥ <
? ?r?
? <kaaA
k
ij
k
ij
k
~),(
)()(
= 8C ? ?r?
),1,,,,
)()()()(
00
nsaaaakkkji
k
js
k
is
k
js
k
is
"=≤≥>
? k@v,A
k
? i?í
íQ? C
i
￥ ?× pA
k
￥?
? ?
w
eAe
eA
kT
k
k
=
∞→
lim
+?_
8C ? ?r?
4.?? ?aQ2?F ?_
￥9
? ?aQ2
a
Bí
íD/a
μí
íM1 ó
?? ?aQ2
!? 2a? 1a ?_
w
(2)
=(w
1
(2)
,w
2
(2)
)
T
X?
? 3a? 2a ?_
w
1
(3)
=(w
11
(3)
,w
12
(3)
,w
13
(3)
,0)
T
w
2
(3)
=(0,0,w
23
(3)
,w
24
(3
)
T
X¤
D O
?D C
1
Sù C
2
P
2
P
1
P
3
P
4
è,
N?
=
D￥aQ2
P
1
,P
2
oT?D,P
4
oT Sù,
P
3
YT?D a Sù b
)
? w
(2)
,W
(3)
=(w
1
(3)
,w
2
(3)
)
9
? 3a? 1a ?_
w
(3
￥ZE
C
1
,C
2
|
￥í
í￥
"??
? C
1
,C
2
×1?M],w
(2)
=(1/2,1/2
)T,
P
1
~P
4
?M],w
1
(3)
=(1/3,1/3,1/3,0)
T
,w
2
(3)
=(0,0,1/2,1/2)
T
?￥
N?1 P
1
:P
2
:P
3
:P
4
=1:1:2:1
I3B?+ è
? I
n|
￥í
í
"??￥?Y
w
(3)
=(1/6,1/6,5/12,1/4)
T
)2()3()3(
wWw =
ˉ¨ 9
?D a Sù ? ?
)?
|
￥í
í ?× v
)/(),(
~
)2(
22
)2(
11
)2(
22
)2(
11
)2(
wnwnwnwnw
T
+=
¨|
￥í
í
" n
1
,n
2
w
(2)
F ???
T
w
nn
)5/2,5/3(
~
,2,3
)2(
21
=
==
¨ 9
)2()3()3(
~
wWw = w
(3)
=(1/5,1/5,2/5,1/5)
T
?D a Sù L? | ?
|
￥í
í ?× l
5,? ??1??￥) ?
=
12/1/
212/1
/21
13
31
ww
ww
C
wCw λ=
=
12/1
212/1
21
θ
θ
A è
θ1? ?í
í
￡ù ?
T
w )1429.0,2857.0,5714.0(,3 ==λ
=
22/10
212/1
022
A
wwA λ=
=+
=≠
≠≠
=
jim
aji
ajia
a
i
ij
ijij
ij
,1
,,0
,,
θ
θ
m
i
~A? i ?
? θ￥?
6,÷ˉ￥aQ2
?¨aQ2 a
=òí
í? ?íMo?Y
|
￥ aW1
7/ a?a.?íQ ??ì b
÷ˉ￥aQ2 a
=òí
íWi Mo?Y
|
￥ aWi Q ??ì b
?? ?
ú
}Z_
?? h?
?
?ú _ ? F
?
ú?
R?
ú 1 ú 2 ú n
……
è
aQsE￥a?
"d? ——|`
jT"d?vs3 a1? a
a8￥
±?Z
Té? %| ——"ds
D ?s
a?
ksi
L¨? ——??D?
M2
) ?.d￥aZ
E?
3 %￥ù5
e±? ——9
eL2T
ü ?L? %|?
°¤
3g? b
aQsE￥ K
?? ——o
VeZ??êa?
á
3?Z?
Y
{ ——??1?
2TY?
?4 ——?4y
íT¨v2T V
4[? | b
Discussions
aQs
?
?
°èyT a
3?￥ %|ù5
#ü6 a
?Z
￥y
í
T1?
H |￥?4ê4 M?
v￥T¨òy
í￥×1?
4[
Saaty? 1970
M}4aQsE
AHP (Analytic Hierarchy Process)
AHP——B? ??D?
M2
￥ a"d aaQ ￥sZE
B aQsE￥'??
è ê4
j31
? ?
"￥1??v? ? a
n¨ a tHq?y
íê4
O(ê4
j31 )
P
2
?
P
1
I
P
3
z
"Sa
C
3
t
C
1
? ?
C
2
n¨
C
4
?
J
C
5
jo
5a
Z?a
“ê4
j31,
±?V?￥B
,
| %|ù5s1 3?aQ
"Sa O5a C
Z?a P
aμ ??í
í òaí
íW￥1"
¨M ?￥°LV
U b
YVMo1? ??ò5
"S￥ ?×#òZ
?
B5￥ ?× b
|
F ?×é?8 ??òZ?
"S￥
?× b
aQsE|??sD?
s2 ?
??[
??ó %|ù5￥?
2T b
aQsE￥'??
?1??
?_
í
í-W
11?¨M
=
1135/13/1
1125/13/1
3/12/117/14/1
55712
3342/11
A
ij
jiijnnij
a
aaaA
1
,0,)( =>=
×
!11?ò5 C
1
,C
2
,…,C
n
"S O￥×1?
ijji
aCC?:
A~?1??
A
^?oQ?
ê
4
j
3
1
1? A ?? C
1
,…,C
n
O￥ ?_
=
" "
"
"
712
42/11
A
?1?￥?Bá f ?
):(2/1
2112
CCa =
):(4
3113
CCa =
):(8
3223
CCa =
Bá1?
?Bá
?1?? ?_
=
n
nnn
n
n
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
A
"
" "
"
"
21
2
2
2
1
2
1
2
1
1
1
??Bá?1 ???Bá￥
?S?
n
wwwW ",,)1(
21
=
jiij
wwa /=
7
?_
~),,(
21
T
n
wwww "=
I3? ?Bá￥ f ?
?1?? ?_
=
n
nnn
n
n
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
w
A
"
" "
"
"
21
2
2
2
1
2
1
2
1
1
1
?1?? ?Bá￥ f ?
nkjiaaa
ikjkij
,,2,1,,, "==?
@
￥?oQ? A? Bá? ?
A￥?1 1 A￥·Bd
,+??1 n
A￥ ?B
_
^?? n ￥+?_
Bá?
?é
A￥BB+?_
VT1 ?_
??Bá ?
?S?
=
￥?
1?? Ayp¨??Kv+?? λ
￥+?_
T1 ?_
w '
wAw λ=
Saaty? |4 1~9——a
ij
|′
1,2,…,9# oQ
1,1/2,…,1/9
?1?? ?_
1?a
ij
2 4 6 8
1 3 5 7 9
ij
a
M]
< <
üA < ' <￥×1?
ji
CC,
L?????
￥
ji
CC,~
a
ij
= 1,1/2,,…1/9
￥×1?D
MQ
? ?DE a1?1?￥y
í?R?V 9?
¨ 1~3,1~5,…1~17,…,1
p
~9
p
(p=2,3,4,5),d+0.1~d+0.9
(d=1,2,3,4)? 27?1? ??
L è/?1?
?
?_
D
L=1?C 1~9?a b
Bá?_ A ???Bá￥
?S?
X? n ¨Bá?￥·Bd
,+??1 n
V￡ n¨?oQ?Kv+?? λ≥n, O λ =n
H1Bá?
1?
=
n
n
CI
λ
?lBá?·S,
CI v?Bá ?×
1
CI ￥vl? ?
Bá?·S RI——
E¤? a
ij
,?? A9
CI '¤ RI b
Saaty￥2T ?/
RI 0 0 0.58 0.90 1.12 1.24 1.32 1.41 1.45 1.49 1.51
n 12345 6 78 9
1110
? CR<0.1
HYVBá?_
?lBá?1
q CR = CI/RI
=
1135/13/1
1125/13/1
3/12/117/14/1
55712
3342/11
A
5a
"S￥ ?1??
oê4
j31 p?
5a
"S￥ ?
_
#Bá?_
Kv+?? λ=5.073
?_
+?_
w =(0.263,0.475,0.055,0.090,0.110)
T
018.0
15
5073.5
=
=CI
Bá?·S
Bá?·S RI=1.12 (°V )
YVBá
?_
Bá?1
q CR=0.018/1.12=0.016<0.1
F ?_
:? 2a
5? 1a
"S
￥ ?_
1
T
n
www ),,(
)2()2(
1
)2(
"=
]" p? 3a (Z? )? 2a
Bí
í (5 )￥ ?_
=
12/15/1
212/1
521
1
B
Z?a C
1
(? ? )
￥?1??
=
138
3/113
8/13/11
2
B
Z?a C
2
(n¨ )
￥?1??
…C
n
…B
n
Kv+?? λ
1
λ
2
…λ
n
?_
w
1
(3)
w
2
(3)
… w
n
(3)
? 3a? 2a￥9
2T
k
)3(
k
w
k
λ
k
CI
1
0.595
0.277
0.129
3.005
0.003 0.001 0 0.005 0
3.002
0.682
0.236
0.082
2
3
0.142
0.429
0.429
3
3.009
0.175
0.193
0.633
4
3
0.668
0.166
0.166
5
F ?_
w
(2)
0.263
0.475
0.055
0.090
0.110
RI 0.58 (n=3),CI
k
( VYVBá?_
Z? P
1
"S￥F ?×1 0.595×0.263+ …=0.300
Z?a
"S￥F ?_
1 (0.300,0.246,0.456)
T
T
n
www ),,(
)2()2(
1
)2(
"=
F
?_
? 1a O
? 2a C
1
,…C
n
? 3a P
1
,…P
m
nkwww
T
kmkk
,,2,1,),,(
)3()3(
1
)3(
" "==
? 2a? 1a￥ ?_
? 3a? 2aòí
í￥ ?_
],,[
)3()3(
1
)3(
n
wwW "=
/ ?
)2()3()3(
wWw =
5? 3a? 1a￥F ?_
? sa? 1a￥F ?_
? W
(p)
^?? pa?
p-1a ?_
F?￥ ?
)2()3()1()()(
wWWWw
sss
"
=
aQsE￥'??
1y ?aQs2
?
' ?s
L=ù5|μ1y
í1
7/sa
"S —
5·S —Z?`
a
s/a?Y7a
=
òy
í'
M? ? b
2/?1??
¨?1?E 1~9/òa
Ba
By
í￥
?1?? b
39
?_
iTBá?_
B?1??9
Kv+??+?_
TBá?
_ ?YV5+?_
1 ?_
b
49
F ?_
TFBá?_
*
F ?_
VT1 %|￥?
G b
= aQsE￥<W?¨
?¨
5× ü695 ?
÷?|s
￥
|?êù
N
3á %|?Y
{ Sùê
5á<2?aD
ìa +
Y? b
) ?ù5 ?? %| a
N as a??? b
y ?aQs2
?
^1oB?1μ?1 %
|a?D b
/?1??
^
G ??ü~? a
? <￥Eó b
SE8
L ?
S
l ?
+
Y
?
S/
￡
ü
×?
?
^
a, a? a ° a￡?vS
è 1SE
L ?s
yTê4
D
l
?
?
Z
2
?
1
"
ê
?
ê4￥?ê
è 2 yTê4
V￥rm
A
ü6rm
B
1
rm
B
2
ìarm
B
3
?
8
H
W
C
1
l
?
C
2
á
W
<
C
3
?
1
<
C
4
y
y
ü
<
C
5
?
?
V
L
C
6
?
a
Y
C
7
1
w
?
C
8
}
a
C
9
é
Z
L
C
10
C
11
B
D
1
a?
D
2
/
D
3
1VrmaQ2
è 3
~ aZ,
Z?￥ 4
V￥}N
A
ü6}N
B
1
ìa}N
B
3
}N
B
2
g
?
'
á
C
1
?
T
?
1
C
2
/
<
C
3
3
Z
T
C
4
?
Y
?
*
C
5
ì
%
C
6
ú
b
t
C
7
￡
￥
ê
?
C
8
3
￥
ê
C
9
B
D
1
a?
D
2
/
D
2
2V}NaQ2
è 3
~ aZ,
Z?￥ 4
?
N￥ S/?T
°¤
ü6
rm
C
11
W¤
ü6
rm
C
12
rm
C
13
D
M
￡
ü
C
21
D
7?
C
22
/
￡
ü
C
23
/
7?
C
24
rm C
1
￡
ü C
2
C
3
S/?T
N
è 4 S/?T
￥8
N
?,aQsE￥ ??ù5
?oQ?￥Kv+??
^?1?
$+?_
^?1?_
$Bá?·S
?Q??oQ?¤
íBá?￥?$
8"e9
?oQ?￥Kv+??+?_
$
1
I
1¨+?_
T1 ?_
$
?aQ2?? ??1??μ b ?
H8"¨
aQsE$
1,?oQ?￥Kv+??+?_
￥?é
? ? ? ? A ￥Kv+?? λ
^????
?+?_
w O
T
kT
k
k
ew
eAe
eA
)1,,1,1(,lim "==
∞→
?oQ?￥Kv+??
^?
+?_
^?_
b
? ? n¨?oQ? A￥Kv+?? λ ? n,
λ= n
^ A1Bá?￥ 1Hq b
Bá?·S ?l ?
1?
=
n
n
CI
λ
2,?oQ?Kv+??+?_
￥e9
ú ?9
￥ˉ?A1
e9
￥
±
^ ——Bá?￥ ?B
_
?
^+?_
Bá?
z￥?oQ?￥
_
??í
+?_
V |
?il/￥
ü ( b
E —— |
_
￥
ü (
=
14/16/1
412/1
621
A è
091.0077.01.0
364.0308.03.0
545.0615.06.0
w=
089.0
324.0
587.0
_
BB
ü (
=
286.0
974.0
769.1
Aw
wAw λ=
009.3)
089.0
268.0
324.0
974.0
587.0
769.1
(
3
1
=++=λ
ú ?2T,w=(0.588,0.322,0.090)
T
,λ=3.010
e
9
?E —— |
_
￥+
ü (
aE ——Y}
E
1 ? |
S_
w
(0)
,k:=0
!?úε
)()1(
~
kk
Aww =
+
2) 9
∑
=
+++
=
n
i
k
i
kk
www
1
)1()1()1(
~
/
~
3BB
4 ? T?
?5 k:=k+1,2
ε<?
+ )()1(
max
k
i
k
i
i
ww
∑
=
+
=
n
i
k
i
k
i
w
w
n
1
)(
)1(
~
1
λ
5) 9
3,+?_
T1 ?_
——?1?￥ ? ?r?
ù5
Bá? A, ?_
w=(w
1
,…w
n
)
T
,a
ij
=w
i
/w
j
A?Bá,?ê ?_
w
P w
i
/w
j
D a
ij
Mμ
D
l
μ i,j) b
2
11
),,1(
min
∑∑
==
=?
n
i
n
j
j
i
ij
niw
w
w
a
i
"
¨
EZE ?? w
dL?
Kl=e
L? ——
Kl=e
2
11
),,1(
lnlnmin
∑∑
==
=?
n
i
n
j
j
i
ij
niw
w
w
a
i
"
2TD?EM]
??]5 ??￥ ?_
?
]+?_
μ
I
1a? b
?1?
C
i
:C
j
(°¤1?
a
ij
~ ? <
)(
)2(2
ij
aA =
sj
n
s
isij
aaa
∑
=
=
1
)2(
a
is
a
sj
~ C
i
YV C
s
D C
j
￥1?
a
ij
(2)
~ 2? <
÷
Q? C
i
C
j
￥ <
? ?r?
? <kaaA
k
ij
k
ij
k
~),(
)()(
= 8C ? ?r?
),1,,,,
)()()()(
00
nsaaaakkkji
k
js
k
is
k
js
k
is
"=≤≥>
? k@v,A
k
? i?í
íQ? C
i
￥ ?× pA
k
￥?
? ?
w
eAe
eA
kT
k
k
=
∞→
lim
+?_
8C ? ?r?
4.?? ?aQ2?F ?_
￥9
? ?aQ2
a
Bí
íD/a
μí
íM1 ó
?? ?aQ2
!? 2a? 1a ?_
w
(2)
=(w
1
(2)
,w
2
(2)
)
T
X?
? 3a? 2a ?_
w
1
(3)
=(w
11
(3)
,w
12
(3)
,w
13
(3)
,0)
T
w
2
(3)
=(0,0,w
23
(3)
,w
24
(3
)
T
X¤
D O
?D C
1
Sù C
2
P
2
P
1
P
3
P
4
è,
N?
=
D￥aQ2
P
1
,P
2
oT?D,P
4
oT Sù,
P
3
YT?D a Sù b
)
? w
(2)
,W
(3)
=(w
1
(3)
,w
2
(3)
)
9
? 3a? 1a ?_
w
(3
￥ZE
C
1
,C
2
|
￥í
í￥
"??
? C
1
,C
2
×1?M],w
(2)
=(1/2,1/2
)T,
P
1
~P
4
?M],w
1
(3)
=(1/3,1/3,1/3,0)
T
,w
2
(3)
=(0,0,1/2,1/2)
T
?￥
N?1 P
1
:P
2
:P
3
:P
4
=1:1:2:1
I3B?+ è
? I
n|
￥í
í
"??￥?Y
w
(3)
=(1/6,1/6,5/12,1/4)
T
)2()3()3(
wWw =
ˉ¨ 9
?D a Sù ? ?
)?
|
￥í
í ?× v
)/(),(
~
)2(
22
)2(
11
)2(
22
)2(
11
)2(
wnwnwnwnw
T
+=
¨|
￥í
í
" n
1
,n
2
w
(2)
F ???
T
w
nn
)5/2,5/3(
~
,2,3
)2(
21
=
==
¨ 9
)2()3()3(
~
wWw = w
(3)
=(1/5,1/5,2/5,1/5)
T
?D a Sù L? | ?
|
￥í
í ?× l
5,? ??1??￥) ?
=
12/1/
212/1
/21
13
31
ww
ww
C
wCw λ=
=
12/1
212/1
21
θ
θ
A è
θ1? ?í
í
￡ù ?
T
w )1429.0,2857.0,5714.0(,3 ==λ
=
22/10
212/1
022
A
wwA λ=
=+
=≠
≠≠
=
jim
aji
ajia
a
i
ij
ijij
ij
,1
,,0
,,
θ
θ
m
i
~A? i ?
? θ￥?
6,÷ˉ￥aQ2
?¨aQ2 a
=òí
í? ?íMo?Y
|
￥ aW1
7/ a?a.?íQ ??ì b
÷ˉ￥aQ2 a
=òí
íWi Mo?Y
|
￥ aWi Q ??ì b
?? ?
ú
}Z_
?? h?
?
?ú _ ? F
?
ú?
R?
ú 1 ú 2 ú n
……
è
aQsE￥a?
"d? ——|`
jT"d?vs3 a1? a
a8￥
±?Z
Té? %| ——"ds
D ?s
a?
ksi
L¨? ——??D?
M2
) ?.d￥aZ
E?
3 %￥ù5
e±? ——9
eL2T
ü ?L? %|?
°¤
3g? b
aQsE￥ K
?? ——o
VeZ??êa?
á
3?Z?
Y
{ ——??1?
2TY?
?4 ——?4y
íT¨v2T V
4[? | b
Discussions
