20
Infrared processing
C. Skj?ldebrand, ABB and Lund University, Sweden
20.1 Introduction: the principles of infrared heating
Sir William Herschel discovered infrared – or heat radiation – in the 1800s when
he was attempting to determine the part of the visible spectrum with the minimum
associated heat in connection with the astronomical observations he was making.
In 1847 AHL Fizeau and JBL Foucault showed that infrared radiation has the
same properties as visible light. It was being reflected, refracted and was capable
of forming an interference pattern (Encyclopedia Internet, 2000). There are many
applications of infrared radiation. A number of these are analogous to the use of
visible light. Thus, the spectrum of a substance in the infrared range can be used
in chemical analysis much as the visible spectrum is used. Radiation at discrete
wavelengths in the infrared range is characteristic of many molecules. The tem-
perature of a distant object can also be determined by analysis of the infrared
radiation from the object.
Medical uses of infrared radiation range from the simple heat lamp to the tech-
nique of thermal imaging, or thermographs. It has also been used for drying dye
and lacquer for cars, glue for wallpaper, paper in paper machines, and dye to
plastic details, as well as shrinkage of plastics and activation of glue in the plastic
industry, etc.
The electromagnetic spectra within infrared wavelengths can be divided into
3 parts; long waves (4mm to 1 mm), medium waves (2–4mm) and short waves
(0.7–2mm). The short waves appear when temperatures are above 1000°C, the
long waves appear below 400°C and the medium waves appear between these
temperatures. The electromagnetic spectrum is shown in Fig. 20.1 (Anon, The
Infrared Handbook). For food the technique has been used in many applications,
as the long waves are one of the main heat transfer mechanisms in ordinary ovens
or other heating equipment. Short waves are new for the food industry.
In the USSR in the 1950s AV Lykow and others reported the results of their
theoretical and experimental studies of infrared drying (Ginzburg, 1969). In the
1960s W Jubitz carried out substantial work on infrared heating in East Germany
and in France M Dáribéré and J Leconte did some work on different applications
of infrared irradiation in various industries. During this time IS Pavlov in the
Soviet Union carried out a lot of work on infrared heating and food. Long wave
radiation was already used in the United States during the 1950s in many indus-
trial food processes.
During the early 1970s there were many discussions concerning finding new
methods for industrial frying/cooking meat products (Skj?ldebrand, 1986). Deep
fat frying, the process most often used in industrial frying, was criticised because
of the fat and flavour exchange and surface appearance. Also, environmental and
nutritional aspects had to be considered. The consumer also wanted products
more like the ones cooked at home. One of the new techniques discussed was
near infrared heating (NIR) or short wave infrared heating. This technique is used
in the car industry for drying coatings, as well as the paper and textile industries.
Thus, like many other processes in the food industry, infrared heating was trans-
ferred from other industries. Therefore, why has short wave infrared radiation not
been used before? The answer is that there was a lack of knowledge about many
of the factors concerning this process. The radiators, the reflectors and the dif-
ferent systems for cassettes were developed during the 1960s but there was not
very much knowledge about the optical properties of the foodstuffs and how these
develop during processing. The problems then were also braking the radiators
and cleaning the equipment.
During the 1970s and 1980s most of the research work on food was carried
424 The nutrition handbook for food processors
0.38 0.76 2 4 mm 1 mm
Visible
light
Short
wave
IR
Med-
ium
wave
IR
Long wave IR
Radiation
designations
Gamma
rays
X-rays
Ultra
violet
rays
Infrared
rays
Radio waves
Wavelength
1 nm 1 mm 1 mm 1 km1 m
10
–9
10
–6
10
–3
10
3
m10
–0
Fig. 20.1 The electromagnetic spectrum (Anon, The Infrared Handbook).
out in Sweden at the Swedish Institute for Food and Biotechnology (SIK)
(Dagerskog and ?sterstr?m, 1979; Skj?ldebrand, 1986; Skj?ldebrand and
Andersson, 1989).
In this chapter the application of infrared processing in the food industry will
cover the following areas:
? Examples of applications in the food industry;
? The infrared process and its impact on quality;
? The infrared process and its impact on nutrition;
? Future outlook.
20.2 Infrared processing in the food industry
The basic concepts of infrared radiation are:
? High heat transfer capacity;
? Heat penetration directly into the product;
? Fast regulation response;
? Good possibilities for process control;
? No heating of surrounding air.
These qualities indicate that infrared radiation should be an ideal source of energy
for heating purposes (Skj?ldebrand, 1986).
Distinguished from microwave heating, the penetration properties of infrared
radiation are such that a suitable balance for surface and body heating can be
reached, which is necessary for an optimal heating result. Some empirical work
in this field can be found in the literature by Ginzburg for example (Ginzburg,
1969). The penetration properties are important for optimising the system. The
penetration depth is defined as 37% of the unabsorbed radiation energy. For short
waves, the penetration ability is ten times higher than for long waves. The direct
penetration ability of infrared radiation makes it possible to increase the energy
flux without burning the surface and thus reduces the necessary heating time that
conventional heating methods require. This is especially true for thin products.
In a special study, a method was developed to determine optical properties of
bread at different degrees of baking (Skj?ldebrand et al, 1988). The results
showed that the transmission by the crust was less than in the crumb. Even the
thinnest dough sample did not transmit any radiation.
Reflection curves for crust and dough are very similar while reflection for the
crumb is about 10–15% less. Table 20.1 shows calculated penetration depths for
crust and crumb for radiators used in baking ovens. Measurements have been
carried out for other foods and Table 20.2 shows some examples (Dagerskog and
?sterstr?m, 1979).
In infrared (IR) heating, heat is transferred by radiation, the wavelength of
which is determined by the temperature of the body – the higher the temperature,
the shorter the wavelength. Present interest in industrial heating applications
centres on short wave IR (wavelengths around 1mm) and intermediate IR (around
Infrared processing 425
10mm), since these wavelengths make it possible to start up and reach working
temperatures in seconds, while also offering rapid transfer of high amounts of
energy and excellent process control. In some food materials, short wave IR
demonstrate penetration depths of up to 5 mm.
The most popular industrial applications (for non-food uses) are in the rapid
drying of automobile paint and drying in the paper and pulp industry. For paper
drying IR has superseded microwaves because it offers superior process control
and economy. IR technology has long been underestimated in the food field,
despite its great potential. Most applications of IR within the area of food came
during the 1950s to 1970s from the USA, the USSR and the eastern European
countries. During the 1970s and 1980s SIK did a lot of basic work applying this
technique within the area of food. In later years work was carried out in Japan,
Taiwan and other countries.
The main part of this work is still of an experimental nature. Applications are
mainly in the following areas:
? Drying vegetables and fish;
? Drying pasta and rice;
426 The nutrition handbook for food processors
Table 20.1 The calculated penetration depths for crust and crumb for radiators used in
baking ovens (Skj?ldebrand et al, 1988)
Maximum
Spectral range
Penetration depth
Power level (%) energy
(nm)
Crumb Crustwavelength
100 1300 800–1250 3.8 2.5
1250–2500 1.4 0.6
800–2500 1.9 1.2
75 1320 800–1250 3.8 2.5
1250–2500 1.4 0.6
800–2500 1.9 1.1
50 1410 800–1250 3.8 2.5
1250–2500 1.4 0.6
800–2500 1.8 1.1
Table 20.2 Measured penetration depths for some foods (Dagerskog and ?sterstr?m,
1979)
Penetration depth
Radiation source
Wavelength range (mm)Product
l
max
(mm)
l<1.25 1.25 <l<1.51 l>1.51
Potato 1.12 4.76 0.48 0.33
Potato 1.24 4.17 0.47 0.31
Pork 1.12 2.38 0.28
Bread 1.12 6.25 1.52
? Heating flour;
? Frying meat;
? Roasting cereals;
? Roasting coffee;
? Roasting cocoa;
? Baking pizza, biscuits and bread.
The technique has also been used for thawing, surface pasteurisation of bread and
surface pasteurisation of packaging materials.
The main commercial applications of IR heating are drying low moisture foods
(for example breadcrumbs, cocoa, flours, grains, malt, pasta products and tea).
The technique is often used at the start of the whole process to speed up the first
increase in surface temperature. Such processes are frying, baking and drying.
The effect of radiation intensity (0.125, 0.250, 0.375 and 0.500 W/cm
2
) and slab
thickness (2.5, 6.5 and 10.5 mm) on the moisture diffusion coefficient of potatoes
during far IR drying have been investigated by Afzal and Abe in 1998 in Japan.
They found that the diffusivity increased with increasing radiation intensity and
with slab thickness. In contrast, activation energy for moisture desorption
decreased with increasing slab thickness and resulted in higher drying rates for
slabs of greater thicknesses. Some more specific examples will be described
below.
20.2.1 Baking
When baking with infrared radiation it seems that short wave radiators should be
used. The short wave infrared radiation may be combined with convection for
drying the surface with good results.
Ginzburg divided the baking process using infrared radiation into three
periods:
1. The first phase is characterised by an increase in the surface temperature
(1–2°C) to 100°C. Very little weight loss occurs during this period.
2. The second period is characterised by the start of mass transfer. An evapo-
ration zone forms, which moves towards the central parts. Energy is used to
evaporate water and to heat the dough.
3. In the third and final period the central parts have reached 90°C. The tem-
perature increases by a further 8°C at the end of baking. The duration of this
period amounts to about 25% of the total time of baking.
When comparing time–temperature relations between infrared radiation and
conventional baking it is clear that IR radiation is more efficient both at the
surface parts and the central sections. The following results were achieved
using short wave infrared heating in the baking oven at SIK (Skj?ldebrand et al,
1994):
? The baking time was 25–50% shorter compared to an ordinary baking oven.
The thickness of the product determined the time saving.
? Energy consumption was comparable to ordinary baking.
Infrared processing 427
? Weight losses were 10–15% lower.
? Quality was comparable.
These results show that infrared heating for bakery products is very promising
compared to other heating techniques.
Further studies at SIK have shown that baking bread using the short wave
infrared heating technique is a very interesting alternative to traditional baking
(Skj?ldebrand and Andersson, 1987). The baking time can be reduced by 25%
and in some cases 50%, depending on the thickness of the product. This is due
to penetration of the waves into the product. Depending on the radiators in the
oven and their wavelength distribution, the penetration properties of the bread
change during baking. At the start they are almost zero, with the crust having
poorer penetration depth than the porous water-rich crumb. The baking time
reduction is also due to the more effective heat transfer to the surface than occurs
in convection or conduction heating. Using short wave infrared radiation may
reduce weight losses. In some of the experiments it was found that the water
content in the centre had increased during baking, causing a better and longer
storage.
20.2.2 Frying meat
Several studies on frying meat by infrared radiation have been carried out by
researchers in the former Soviet Union. There have also been studies carried out
in Sweden. These studies have shown that maximum transmission falls in the
region of the electromagnetic spectrum of 1.2mm. For wavelengths over 2.5mm
the transmission capacity was negligible (Bolshakov et al, 1976). Consequently
it was necessary to use sources with maximum radiation falling in the region of
maximum transmission to achieve deep heating of pork. For heat treatment of the
product surface, radiators in the region of maximum transmission and reflectance
(l > 2.3mm) had to be used. It was recommended to design a two-stage frying
process. In the first stage surface heat treatment was achieved by radiant flux with
l at maximum 1.04mm providing deep heat to the product. The studies showed
that the final moisture content and sensory quality of the product were higher
when heated by the two-stage process than by conventional methods.
20.3 Infrared processing and food quality
The improvements in bread quality from using the baking oven at SIK mentioned
earlier were achieved using short wave infrared heating (Skj?ldebrand et al,
1994). Suggestions have been made that radiant heating elements should be oper-
ated at temperatures between 1200 and 1800°C as only wavelengths longer than
2mm are effective in developing colour in particular. Successful results have also
been reported for several frying applications (Dagerskog, 1978).
Four different frying methods were compared in work carried out by
researchers at Lund University and at SIK. The product studied was a meat patty
428 The nutrition handbook for food processors
(Dagerskog and S?renfors, 1979). They studied convection, deep fat frying,
contact and long wave IR, and found that from pure heat transfer considerations
the four techniques gave almost equivalent results if appropriate frying condi-
tions were used. The surface crust of the meat was, however, rather different for
the four methods, influencing the sensorial experience. For IR and convection
frying the crust was similar with burned areas and a skin-like surface, but the
periphery of the meat patty was browned first during convection heating in con-
trast to IR heating, where the surface area was browned first. For flavour, no dif-
ference among the methods were found, except for deep fat frying which gave a
significantly stronger ‘off-flavour’, probably due to the absorbed fat. The juici-
ness of the IR fried meat patties was rated by the panel because of the excep-
tionally long frying times needed, which in turn was due to the recipe. The results
also showed that it was very important to have the recipe tailor-made for the tech-
nique used. In this study it was also reported that, as expected, the surface crust
became darker as intensity levels grew higher. However, the total impression
scores indicate an optimum at intermediate levels. The optimum levels often coin-
cided for both texture, flavour and brightness.
When parboiling at a similar degree of heat treatment as compared with con-
ventional technology, the infrared treatment required a shorter time (83%) with
lower weight losses (50%). The flavour, colour and texture of the infrared braised
meat were claimed to be far superior (Asselberg et al, 1960).
Researchers testing a baking oven in a Swedish bakery during the 1980s found
that the colour for ordinary wheat bread was very good and acceptable but the
evenness could be better. This was due to the fact that radiation cannot be dis-
tributed evenly to all bread sides in an optimal way. The volume and the poros-
ity were very good and comparable to ordinary baked bread (Skj?ldebrand et al,
1988). The products tested were sweet rolls, buns, baguettes, white bread loaves
and rye bread loaves. It is, however, difficult to use steam in a baking oven when
using NIR as the water molecules absorb the waves. Weight losses for some of
the baked products are about the same when baking in an NIR oven as in a con-
ventional oven. However, the baking times are reduced by 25–30% when using
short wave infrared radiation as a heating technique. The reduction depends on
geometry and thickness of the product. In general it was found that volume
increased in bread baked in an infrared oven compared to bread baked in a con-
ventional oven.
Colour is comparable if flat bread is baked. It was found that as energy levels
reach 100% white spots occur on the bread surface, due to ungelatinised starch.
Also, big pores or even holes in the crumb can occur when too high energy levels
are used in a baking oven based on infrared heating. However, as there is a fast
response when changing energy levels, the heat transfer may be controlled to get
an optimised colour on the surface.
An industrial process for pre-cooking of bacon in a continuous infrared oven
at Swift & Company has been investigated by Hlavacek (1968). Electric resis-
tance heaters below the seamless stainless steel belt supplemented the 288 kW of
infrared radiant heating from overhead quartz lamps. The frying time was 2–3
Infrared processing 429
minutes and pre-cooked bacon was found to taste as good or better than freshly
fried bacon. The results showed that the final moisture content and sensory quality
of the product heated by the two-stage process were higher than those heated by
conventional methods. In Taiwan IR has also been used for dehydration of fish.
Over 90% of the far IR dried products were of a higher quality than currently
marked sun dried products (Wei-Renn-Lein and Wen-Rong-Fu, 1997).
20.4 Infrared processing and nutritional quality
There are very few studies in the literature on the infrared process and its impact
on food nutrients. However, some of it is reported here. Comparisons between
conventional heating techniques and infrared heating give some hints as to their
effect on the nutritional value of heated products.
Recent studies of intense IR radiation treatment on nutritional value and anti-
nutritional factors of cereals (corn, rice, brown sorghum) and common beans
show that digestibility and energy values were not altered significantly but protein
quality decreased (Keya-EL and Sherman U, 1997). No anti-nutritional factors
were found in rice. Tannin in sorghum was denatured extensively by IR treat-
ment. Small amounts of aflatoxins in corn and sorghum trypsin inhibitors in
common beans were destroyed.
Mackerel were dried in IR radiation at 180°C for 40 minutes and the results
revealed better nutritional values than after conventional treatment (Shyue-Bin-
Ho, En-Chie-Lin, Fu-Jin-Wang and Sheu-Der-Wu, 1996). The Maillard reaction
in the crust of bread or meat can be better controlled when using NIR heating
than using grilling or frying or in an ordinary baking oven. This is due to the fast
response when changing the energy levels of radiators. However, too high energy
transfer at the start of the process may give white spots of ungelatinised starch.
As the IR heating technique in most applications shows shorter drying, frying
or heating times for food nutrition, spoilage is less than that of most conventional
techniques. The spoilage can also be controlled in a better way. Knowing the
kinetics of the chemical reaction of different nutritional components and using
mathematical models based on knowledge about the IR heating temperature and
mass transfer is one way to optimise the nutritional value of the ready-made
product (Skj?ldebrand, 2000).
20.5 Future trends
The infrared technique of heating foods shows a lot of advantages compared to
conventional techniques. These cover both process aspects as well as nutritional
and quality aspects. However, the technique is not widely used in the industry.
? More knowledge about the interaction between processes and products needs
to be gained. The relationship between raw material properties and how these
are affected by the process to obtain the desired properties in the end product
430 The nutrition handbook for food processors
should be studied. These are necessary for the success of using new tech-
niques like NIR or short wave infrared heating equipment.
? IR heating should be particularly useful for continuous baking, drying and
grilling as well as for surface pasteurisation.
? All different heating techniques have their own limitations concerning appli-
cation areas and possibilities. Good background knowledge may combine the
techniques in the most optimal way. More knowledge is important for the
success of the heating technique.
? The use of IR technology in the food industry is quite limited today, and the
available equipment is not optimised for the various heating operations along
the processing lines for baking, drying, etc. Its application is certain to grow
as food equipment manufacturers begin to realise its full potential.
? Along with the development of process control and information technology
the IR technique will show its full potential with fast regulation of radiators
and rapid heat transfer.
? IR heating will certainly fulfil its role in the requirements of flexible produc-
tion units.
? With the development of new products the heating technique will be impor-
tant and used. New flavour can be created via both the recipe and the heating
technique.
The combination of different heating techniques is probably a meaningful road
to examine for heating of food in the most optimal way (W?hlby, 2002). There
are already several types of combination ovens available on the market; essen-
tially these types of ovens are based on microwave technology with conventional
technology added. From a food quality point of view this is an interesting field
– how to optimise combinations of heating technologies. The IR technology
should probably be used at the start of the heating procedure or a stepwise
combination of different power levels should be designed. In drying the NIR
technology should be used and with a stepwise change from high to low power
levels.
The behaviour of food has been explored quite a bit, but the introduction of
new sensing techniques (e.g. gas sensing, IR, radio and microwave) shows that
there are several areas of research to be continued. By using the new sensing
technologies, it may be possible to let food control the process on-line. To be able
to do this, a good relationship between these sensor outputs and food quality is
necessary. When this is known the quality and the nutritional value of food can
be controlled better and the correct heating technique can be selected.
20.6 References
afzal t m and abe t (1998), ‘Diffusion in potatoes during far infrared radiation drying’,
Journal of Food Engineering 37(4), 353–65
anon, The Infrared Handbook, Philips
asselberg e a, mohr w p and kemp j g (1960), Food Technology 14, 449
Infrared processing 431
bolshakov a s, bouskov v g, kasulin g n, rogov f a, skryabin u p and zhukov n n
(1976), Effects of Infrared radiation rates and conditions of preliminary processing of
quality index on baked products, 22
nd
European meeting of meat research workers,
Malm?, Sweden
dagerskog m (1978), Stekning av livsmedel pHD thesis, Gothenburg (In Swedish)
dagerskog m and ?sterstr?m l (1979), Infrared radiation for food processing. A study
of the fundamental properties of infrared radiation. Lebensmittel Wissenschaft u. Tech-
nologie 12, 237–42
fellows p (1988), Food Processing Technology Principles and Practice Ellis Horwood,
Chichester, England and VCH, Weinheim, Germany
ginzburg a s (1969), Application of Infrared Radiation in Food Processing Leonard Hill,
London
hallstr?m b, tr?g?rdh c and skj?ldebrand c (1988), Heat transfer and food prod-
ucts Elsevier Science, London
hlavacek r g (1968), Food Proc. 28, 51
keya-el and sherman u (1997), ‘Effects of a brief, intense infrared radiation treatment
on the nutritional quality of maize, rice, sorghum and beans’, Food and Nutrition
Bulletin 18(4), 382–7
shyue-bin-ho, en-chie-lin, fu-jin-wang and sheu-der-wu (1996), ‘The study on pro-
cessing smoked mackerel slices by far infrared heating’. Food Science – Taiwan (In
Chinese) 23(6), 801–8
skj?ldebrand c (2000), ‘Infrared heating’ in Thermal technologies in food processing.
Chapter 9 (Ed Philip Richardsson) p 208–28 Woodhead Publishing Ltd, Cambridge,
England
skj?ldebrand c (1986), Cooking by Infrared Radiation In Proceedings from Progress in
Food Preparation processes, p 157–73
skj?ldebrand c and andersson c g (1989), ‘A comparison of infrared bread baking and
conventional baking’ Journal of Microwave Power and Electromagnetic energy 24,
91–101
skj?ldebrand c and andersson c g (1987), Baking using short wave infrared radia-
tion. Proceedings from Cereals in a European Context, First European Conference
on Food Science and Technology. Chapter 7.6 (Ed ID Morton) Ellis Horwood,
Chichester, UK, p 364–76
skj?ldebrand c and falk c (1990), Development of a simulation programme for IR
heating. Engineering and Food Vol 1 Physical properties and process control. (Eds
Spiess WEL and Schubert H) Proceedings of the Fifth International Congress on
Engineering and Food 28 May–3 June 1989, Cologne Federal Republic of Germany
London p 869–86
skj?ldebrand c and schmidt m (1985), Kortare bakningstider med ny teknik. Br?d kon-
ditorn 11.22. (In Swedish)
skj?ldebrand c, ellbj?r c, andersson c g and eriksson t (1988), ‘Optical properties
of Bread in the Near Infrared Range’ Journal of Food Engineering 8, 129–39
skj?ldebrand c, van den hark s, janestad h and andersson c g (1994), Radiative
and convective heat transfer when baking dough products, Proceedings from the Fourth
Bath Food Engineering Conference, University of Bath, UK 19–21 September
wei-renn-lein and wen-rong-fu (1997), ‘Small fish dehydration by far infrared
heating’. Food Science Taiwan 24(3), 348–56 (In Chinese)
w?hlby u (2002), Heat and Mass Transfer in Impingement Cooking – Aspects of Food
Quality. PH D thesis, Gothenburg, Sweden
432 The nutrition handbook for food processors