Solution 4.6.3.5
The characteristic equation is
1+
K
(s +3)
3
=0;;
which can be rewritten as
s
3
+9s
2
+27s +(K +27)
(s +3)
3
=0;;
or
s
3
+9s
2
+27s +(K +27)=0:
The initial Routh table is
s
3
1 27 0
s
2
9 K +27 0
s
1
b
1
b
2
0
s
0
c
1
0 0
.
Then
b
1
=
;Det
"
1 27
9 K +27
#
9
=
;(K ;216)
9
b
2
=
;Det
"
1 0
9 0
#
9
=
;(0;0)
9
=0
The partially completed Routh table is
s
3
1 27 0
s
2
9 K +27 0
s
1
;(K;216)
9
0 0
s
0
c
1
0 0
.
Then
c
1
=
;Det
"
9 K +27
;(K;216)
9
0
#
;(K;216)
9
= K +27
The completed Routh table is
1
s
3
1 27 0
s
2
9 K +27 0
s
1
;(K;216)
9
0 0
s
0
K +27 0 0
.
For all the terms in the rst column to be positivewemust have
;(K ;216)
9
> 0 and K +27> 0;;
or, equivalently
;27 <K<26:
The lower bound comes from the complementary root locus whichwewill
study in Chapter 5.
2