Solution 4.6.2.4
The characteristic polynomial is
p(s)=s
4
+5s
3
+0s
2
;20s;16:
The initial Routh table is
s
4
1 0 -16 0
s
3
5 -20 0 0
s
2
b
1
b
2
0 0
s
1
c
1
c;2 0 0
s
0
d
1
0 0 0
.
Then
b
1
=
;Det
"
1 0
5 ;20
#
5
=
;(;20;0)
5
=4
b
2
=
;Det
"
1 ;16
5 0
#
5
=
;(0+ 80
5
= ;16
b
3
=
;Det
"
1 0
5 0
#
5
=
;(0;040)
7
=0
The partially completed Routh table is now
s
4
1 0 -16 0
s
3
5 -20 0 0
s
2
4 ;16 0 0
s
1
c
1
c
2
0 0
s
0
d
1
0 0 0
.
c
1
=
;Det
"
5 ;20
4 ;16
#
4
=
;(80;80)
4
= 0
1
c
2
=
;Det
"
5 0
4 0
#
110=7
=
;(0;0)
110=7
= 0:
Thus, wehaveazero row. The auxilliary equation is
4S
2
;16 = 0;;
yielding
s = ;2 and s =2:
Thus weknowtwoofthe four roots. Todetermine is there is more than one
root in the right half plane, weletc
1
= ,toobtain
s
4
1 0 -16 0
s
3
5 -20 0 0
s
2
4 ;16 0 0
s
1
0 0 0
s
0
d
1
0 0 0
.
Then
c
2
=
;Det
"
4 ;16
0
#
=
;(0+16)
= ;1:
The completed Routh arrayis
s
4
1 0 -16 0
s
3
5 -20 0 0
s
2
4 ;16 0 0
s
1
0 0 0
s
0
;1 0 0 0
.
There is one sign change in the rt column, therefore one root in the left
half of the s plane. This is veried bytheMATLAB dialogure:
2
EDU>p = [1 5 0 -20 -16]
p=
1 5 0 -20 -16
EDU>roots(p)
ans =
-4.0000
2.0000
-2.0000
-1.0000
EDU>
3